I've done quite a bit of whisky experimenting inspired by this thread over the past few months. I've discovered I really don't like the peaty/medicinal tastes which the Islays I've tried seem to have. Much more of a Speyside man I think, sherry or port cask finished. To be fair the "Gentleman Jack" wife bought for valentines has been one of my favourites. Haven't had Bushmills Irish whiskey in over 30 years but have ordered one as it was a favourite back in the day. Currently sipping a Glen Moray "Elgin Classic" port cask finish which is very nice.