Don't dismiss trying the ERA Gold V. I had one until recently. It's a lovely phono stage. I've since bought a Reflex M, which is a little more detailed, but to be honest, the ERA Cold V was just as enjoyable. It has a 'wideband' sounding presentation, you get the impression of very tight, extended bass and a top end that reveals all cleanly. Neutrality and depth are very good. You'd never guess whether it was solid state or valve unless you looked. It just does everything right.
It is impossible for anything digital to sound analogue, because it isn't analogue!