DIY Audio....or how many solder burns have you had?

[willbewill]

I keep an Aloe Vera plant handy for solder (and other) burns, works a treat - just cut a piece off and rub the inside goo over the burn.

[Barry]

SMPS have lower noise than an LPS assuming both implemented properly, is that not true?

My only experience with SMPS is with the little triangular 'wall warts' used to charge mobile phones. I have one plugged into a double socket along with the bedside radio (analogue). If the phone is being charged, there is a background noise on the radio. This does not occur if I use a charger plugged into a socket on the other side of the bed. I don't know if the interference is mains borne, or if it is RFI.

[Macca]

My only experience with SMPS is with the little triangular 'wall warts' used to charge mobile phones. I have one plugged into a double socket along with the bedside radio (analogue). If the phone is being charged, there is a background noise on the radio. This does not occur if I use a charger plugged into a socket on the other side of the bed. I don't know if the interference is mains born or if it is RFI.

Possibly the problem is with the radio's PS not filtering very well? Hard to draw any definite conclusion without testing the specific application.

I use a mobile phone charger to power a DAC and there's no noise I can hear even up close to the speaker. It's plugged into the same multi-way block as the pre-amp and transport. I can't discriminate it from the other DAC I own, which has twin built-in LPS.

[Barry]

It has just dawned on me that my TV (a Sony) uses a SMPS, but clearly it does not affect the picture.

Even if an LPS did improve matters, I'm not going to bugger around in trying.

[Bksabath]

Same of My fingers don't burn any more

[Barry]

Possibly the problem is with the radio's PS not filtering very well? Hard to draw any definite conclusion without testing the specific application.

I use a mobile phone charger to power a DAC and there's no noise I can hear even up close to the speaker. It's plugged into the same multi-way block as the pre-amp and transport. I can't discriminate it from the other DAC I own, which has twin built-in LPS.

Agree, it is difficult to ascertain if the interference is mains-borne, or if it radiated. It doesn't seem to matter how close the phone is to the radio, nor does playing around with the radio's telescopic aerial alter the effect. So that would exclude RFI, whereas moving the charger to another socket solves the problem, which suggests the interference is mains borne.

The radio is an old Roberts radio, designed and manufactured long before digital and SMPS became prevalent.

[Mr. C]

Well Martin

I spend maybe 30% of my week working on PDN's / IoT / medical and other switching power devices which the key criteria’s are lower more efficient power with a smaller footprint which is the correct way forward. However, to obtain a real quality low noise smps then the use of many methods is employed including specialist materials, careful high side layout and magnetics, low side with linear tracking regulators, in depth DC<>DC filtering (post smps).

Have tried many very well thought out smps designs on a few audio amplifiers (and RF ones lol) it works perfectly fine and with proper consideration can pass the UKCA/CE Cisper regulations.

90% of my lab bench power supplies are linear I have one half and half a Rohde & Schwarz smps with linear tracking regs, it’s the same size and the equivalent LPS but half the weight. and 2.5 times the amount of ripple noise.

only very, very few clients are specifying class 'a' designs these days for a multitude of reasons one being the physcial size, the weight of the unit, the power consumption and sheer heat they generate.

Lets look @ your Krell KSA50S it takes pretty much 345Watts of power @240Vac at idle which is roughly 450Va which for a quoted genuinely 50W class 'a' device is on the money at more realistic volume levels this isn't going to rise to much as the devices (FET's) are 100% duty cycle as in on permanently all of the time.

So, in 20 hours you will have used 0.35 of Kwh x 20 so around the 7Kwh @ the capped rate of 0.34p per Kwh gives you £2.38 for the amplifier total electrical use (plus whatever the rest of the system uses in that period) so compared to a EV being charge at bollock charge between £40-£70 yes its relative indeed.

A class a/b amplifier is around 55-65% efficient so you could reduce that outlay by a further 25-30% and with a class 'd' style amplification by at least 100%, this is not about which one sounds better purely on consumption.

Also you have a small amplifier in terms of most of the current class 'a' units which are out there, recently visited a cleint who use the older big krell mono's with the meters on them, you could literally wtach the electric meter jump to warp when he switched them on.

Although the big Gryphon Colosseum’s idle around 3.2Kw each and double up as house heaters but do sound superb.



Personally class 'a' has never worked for me, plenty of others yes most are overly safe and somewhat nice which is why the big fad for class 'a' was kicked off in the mid 80's due to the slew of forward, hard sounding glut of average solid state amps but a multitude of manufacturers.

Back to would I use a correct smps in any audio products like amps, maybe one or two designs would lend themselves to this for sure (would it sound better or worse or yes, but as I mentioned cost is the key here), however for myself and the designs we create not yet Martin.

[Mr. C]

SMPS have lower noise than an LPS assuming both implemented properly, is that not true?

For very small psu for IoT and wearable tech work I would say yes, simply due to the nano size, we have devices that 'sleep' using pico (One million millionth (10-12) of an ampere.) or femto amps, (One quadrillionth of an ampere. An ampere being the SI base unit of electric current. 1 Femtoampere = 10-15 amperes. 1 pA = 0.000 000 000 000 001 A.) microscopic amount of currents.

Yes you can easily measure the amount of both radited and conducted rf noise from any electrical device with a quality spectrum analyser/ A/C power analyser/ H & E field probes and for current a good DVM with mA and pA ranges all calibrated. You may also require emc tent/ testing chamber etc.

All of this has to checked and tested by an approved CE / UKCA testing facility for the relevent standrards according to each product being sold.

For higher currents and lower noise then LPS is the way to go if you wish to spend the money. remeber with a traditional LPS then you only have here in the UK 50 cycles @ second in which to fill that capacitor with a smps you can have upto 250K times a second to fill it, hence why they are much smaller caps on a smps but MUCH more RF noise. You have to kill the noise for both conducted and radited emmissions along with some form of dc filtering.

[struth]

must be some pricey EV charger to be that amount.. mine is under £20 for full charge.

so compared to a EV being charge at bollock charge between £40-£70 yes its relative indeed.

[Mr. C]

Overnight charge yes Grant I would suggest so, but stopping at a 'ev station for a fast charge is more'

I'm not getting into whether EV's are better or worse, (I also design many items that are used on EV's including power train products) we have to do everything we can to reduce our all emcompassing emmissions yes, but this is going to require a conserted effort ALL round for many aspects of life.

Not convinced by EV's for many reasons, this is my view they are many others who do not share this. back to smps
V's LPS