I'd try the Counterpoint with the 909, you never know, it may work well. Failing that, a decent passive would definitely sound good.
I like Quad power amps, but their pre-amps (that I've tried) have not impressed.
The cheap Little Bear passive sounded better in my system than the Tisbury did. I sold the Tisbury and kept the Little Bear. (also made an Alps Blue pot passive with two selectable inputs that sounds just fine ).
It is impossible for anything digital to sound analogue, because it isn't analogue!