Sorry John, not sure I understand, do you mean you tried to set up a blind test and involve a particular individual? If so, I can't say I am surprised - forum memberships are similar to the regulars in the pub - there's always someone who's done that, seen that, knows the brother of the best friend of the bloke who did it first etc - dig a bit deeper and it's often just hot air. Also, most members are more at home with armchair theorising than actually putting any of their ideas to the test!
That's why I offered to make some CD mats for people to try. I thought Marco and Co. would be prepared to give it a go and they are easy enough to make - better than just randomly hypothesising.