Valves, I think I'm starting to understand what the fuss is about.
Yesterday I took delivery of a WD KEL84 amp which I purchased off Martin (smurfbrain). Up until now I've never used a valve amp in my system other than a Chinese valve preamp which was a bit crap. :lol: I've heard some very nice valve amps in other systems and liked what I heard, so I decided the KEL84 seemed like a inexpensive but well respected amp to try out.
I wasn't really sure what to expect from the KEL84 in my system as my speakers are fairly difficult to drive and I listed to a lot of powerful, dynamic music. So in switching between my 550W solid state monoblocks to a tiny 15W valve amp I was at least expecting to have less bass punch and extension and less dynamics. I was quite wrong. In some ways the KEL84 seems to provide more punch and just as much bass extension. It does perhaps lack the level of dynamics that my monoblocks are capable of but there's not a huge difference if I'm honest.
I was half expecting the valves to improve the midrange over my monoblocks seen as this is one area that valve are supposed to excel. The KEL84 definitely provided a different tonal balance in the midrange, with male voices seeming more detailed and emotive. Stereo imaging in this department was also improved. There is however a little more warmth in the lower midrange which I'm not sure whether I like. This warmth reminds me of difference between my Alps Blue Velvet based passive attenuator and my LDR based attenuator. As I plan to use the KEL84 with my LDR attenuator I think that removing the volume control and input selector from the KEL84 will yield some improvements in the midrange.
As I hear a lot of people saying that valve amps sound less bright/harsh that solid state amps I was expecting the KEL84 to be more subdued in the treble department. This doesn't seem to be the case but the treble does seem to be slightly more airy and possibly less fatiguing, although I didn't really find my solid state amps fatiguing. The only negative in this area seems to be that the timing seems a little off on some fast sparkly cymbal passages. I have one track where every hi-hat tish constantly swaps from left to right on every hit. This channel swapping is very obvious with my monoblocks whereas the KEL84 seems to smear the effect. This is probably another area that will improve once the amp is converted to a power amp. If not I guess some better valves may help.
So in summary, I've found the KEL84 to be a very capable amp which can hold it's own against a pair of solid state monoblocks which are technically worth over three times as much based on rrp. While I've found the KEL84 to be slightly lacking in a couple of areas I feel this can be improved on with some very simple tweaks. The main eye opener for me has been that I do seem to be able to drive my speakers off a low powered valve amp with surprisingly good results, with the big surprise being that I actually seem to be getting a better bass sound which is completely opposite to what I expected.
So my first proper valve experience has been a good one and it's given me a taste of what valves have to offer. I like what I'm hearing and I want more. I think I might be a valve convert. :eek: Now look what you've gone and done. :lol:
Thanks again to Martin for packing the amp up so well. :cool: