On closer inspection the gold part where the cantilever joins the cartridge is like new and on his photo it looks all greenish and the gold on mine is spotless it doesn't even have the black mark on the left?
On his there is load of dirt in the gap beneath the stylus as you look top down, again mine looks spotless, I think he's bought this one realised it was crap and then sold it on but used other photos to describe it.

