Log in

View Full Version : Ella Fitzgerald Sings Rodgers & Hart Song Book



magiccarpetride
22-02-2011, 23:06
Got this double CD as a gift, and sat down for a listen. The first song came on ("Have You Met Miss Jones") and I was absolutely shocked at the clarity of sound. I was expecting some muddy recording from the olden times, and instead got this modern sounding, full blown orchestral track that kicks in with incredible energy. The next song ("You Took Advantage Of Me") started relaxed, just a piano and Ella, and then when the drums and the bass kicked in, I got startled. Sounded so palpable, so 'right here'.

What got me confused is that these songs sound as if they were recorded today, using the latest technology, while at the same time Ella's voice sounds so fresh and young and light. At first I thought that this must be some of those far fetched mashups where they take the old vocal and put it on top of the rearranged new recording.

So I jumped on the web, and got shocked when I found out that this was recorded back in 1958! (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ella_Fitzgerald_Sings_the_Rodgers_%26_Hart_Songboo k) How's that possible? I wasn't aware that tapes from that era can sound so brilliantly present and fresh.

Ali Tait
22-02-2011, 23:44
They used valve kit and knew what they were doing.Didn't use loads of compression either!

Beechwoods
23-02-2011, 07:43
The key thing is they knew how to mic a room properly. The tape decks at that time had frequency response from 50hz to 16khz, plenty for hi-fi recording done carefully.

I've not heard Ella's recordings, but I know some of the 50's jazz recordings I have sound fantastic, like they were recorded yesterday frankly.

John
23-02-2011, 07:51
Yeah some of those 50 jazz recordings just are special, it just reminds me have we truly moved forward in this field, in terms of how easy to record yes but in terms of quality I think probarly not

magiccarpetride
23-02-2011, 17:24
The key thing is they knew how to mic a room properly. The tape decks at that time had frequency response from 50hz to 16khz, plenty for hi-fi recording done carefully.

I've not heard Ella's recordings, but I know some of the 50's jazz recordings I have sound fantastic, like they were recorded yesterday frankly.

Another one that's equally stunning is Nina Simone's "Little Girl Blue" album from 1957. You literally feel she's with you in the room.