PDA

View Full Version : Hernia Problems



kenworthy100
18-10-2026, 19:58
in 2023 I had two hernias which were small around 4mm neck but needed to be repaired because they were causing constipation and alot of pain. They were what medics call occult ie they didn't create a palpable bump and could only be verified by ultrasound. NHS guidelines wouldn't treat without an extended fight so ended up with a private surgery at significant cost.

Fast forward three years and the hernias have recurred with far worse symptoms, again no bump, ultrasound now confirms one of two. The original surgeon used a very large deep mesh occupying most of my right side which was either incorrectly positioned or has partially lifted on one corner reducing rigidity and creating a tug of war and alot of pain

One surgeon I saw got me to pay for a private resting ct scan which didn't show the hernias and said he wouldn't do anything as a result, he accepted i was in severe pain but just said go to a pain clinic, despite the fact that they are causing bowel and other problems.

i am now in the position where the NHS may treat the one that the ultrasound confirms but leave the other, the surgeons I have contacted said this would be very dangerous to the untreated one potentially altering the properties of the mesh and rendering the newly repaired one likely to fail almost instantly

A leading hernia clinic have now quoted in excess potentially of £25000 as they say they may need to remove a good percentage of the mesh before they can repair with a new mesh and may need to do some abdominal wall reconstruction, they have said this as a guide and because of the mesh size it could be in excess of this

So ladies and gents what would you do here, the stupid little things are making me feel like sh*t and i cannot work or really live, i do not have any immediate family and feel as though my life is on hold, I am 57 and want to move on but just really dont know how?

TLDR Two hernias repaired, repair fails 3 years, pain and complications, NHS will only treat half jeopardising other half, private repair could cost £25k because of complexity and potential mesh removal.

hifi_dave
19-10-2026, 16:46
John, sorry can't provide any decent help or recommendations. The past 7 years I have spent probably a year or more in hospital with Kidney x'plant, Diverticulitis with 1.9mtrs of Intestine removed, Stoma fitted then removed, various weeks in hospital culminating in 2 months for a heart op last year. I am now traumatised and started on anti depressants to help me walk again. Doesn't help you but might show some solidarity with a fellow also suffering.

Would there be any mileage in you rocking up at Addenbrookes A&E with your problems and pleading for help ? You might have already been there but they do things other hospitals won't even consider.

kenworthy100
19-10-2026, 17:08
Thanks Dave, sorry to hear of your troubles, it takes a brave man to go through all that and come out the other side, so please hang in there

As to Addenbrookes you are not the first person to suggest it, the problem for me is the logistics as I am on my own and not very mobile, my local hospital is Broomfield who are really not the best and i would only go to in an absolute emergency

Alex_UK
20-10-2026, 13:28
Don't have much to offer in terms of practical advice, John, but my sympathy is with you and I hope you get a good outcome.

Pigmy Pony
20-10-2026, 15:09
I echo Alex's sentiments and also have no practical advice. Other than perhaps getting caught trying to rob a bank. It seems prisoners get fairly prompt healthcare ;)

If I lived close by I'd drive you to Addenbrookes meself.

hifi_dave
20-10-2026, 16:06
Thanks Dave, sorry to hear of your troubles, it takes a brave man to go through all that and come out the other side, so please hang in there

As to Addenbrookes you are not the first person to suggest it, the problem for me is the logistics as I am on my own and not very mobile, my local hospital is Broomfield who are really not the best and i would only go to in an absolute emergency

That's only a bit of what I've had to endure. I'm not brave, you just have to go with it.

From what I've seen on the local TV, Broomfield isn't the best. Addenbrookes certainly trumps them and has many referrals from other hospitals. When I was having the transplant there was one chap helicoptered in from Ireland and the week before, a chap in for the 'mixed grill' which was just about everything replaced - Heart, lungs, Kidney, Liver, Spleen. A 24 hour job which Addenbrookes pioneered.

I don't know how these things work but maybe Broomfield just hasn't the expertise and so turned you down. Perhaps Addenbrookes would take you on if you turned up in pain and distress and didn't mention previous investigations ? Would be worth a try, I can't see them turning you down flat.

I wish you well.

Patrick Dixon
21-10-2026, 13:09
Sorry to read of your various medical issues and hope they get resolved (to some degree) soon.

To the original poster: since your operation was private, and the problems have reoccurred relatively soon after, and are to some degree exacerbated by the operation, is there any mileage in consulting a medical negligence lawyer?

Lawrence001
22-10-2026, 21:16
Sorry to hear of your problems. The mesh issue reminded me of the vaginal mesh scandal and I found some helpful information here about finding a lawyer to help if you want to consider that route. Also look at your house insurance policy some have legal expenses and I don't know if it covers medical negligence but if it does you might as well ask someone for advice.

https://resolution.nhs.uk/vaginal-mesh/#toc-item-4

kenworthy100
23-10-2026, 18:14
Thanks for the kind words everyone, in all honesty this had made me feel so low that pursuing a negligence claim is a bridge too far at the moment. The advice given by a couple of firms is really to record and note everything, they have also ensured that the three year limitation period only started when i experienced the first recurrent symptoms. As with everything legal the average settlement/ court action takes around 2-3 years.

Patrick Dixon
25-10-2026, 12:35
I think the point of consulting a specialist lawyer would not be to end up in court, but to use it as a lever to get some action to resolve your issues medically. Sadly you have to shout loudest to get some action in this world, and when you are not feeling your best, that's usually the last thing you want or are able to do. So if you can find someone to advocate for you (may be there's a charity), that could help.

Anyway, good luck!