View Full Version : MiniDisc. Regaining Popularity?
walpurgis
09-09-2018, 22:50
I've noticed that second hand prices for MiniDisc players and recorders and just discs seem to be on the up. This includes personal units and decks. I wonder why?
It is a format I actually like a lot. I have several personal units amd a good Pioneer deck. Not that I ever use them these days.
The recording quality with a good deck is amazingly good. Recordings I've made on my deck from my main CD setup sound virtually indistinguishable from the original, in other words, outstandingly good.
Are we seeing a revival? Could be fun!
Martyn Miles
11-09-2018, 21:12
As far as I’m concerned minidisc never went away. I have a Tascam prof. unit and its quality is superb.
I bought it to replace an old cassette deck, mainly to record from a tuner.
I bought a pre-recorded Simon & Garfunkel MD on eBay and compared it to the S & G CD I have.
To be honest, I couldn’t tell the difference...
walpurgis
11-09-2018, 21:19
Yup. My Pioneer MJ-D707 deck makes remarkable recordings. Even the little Sharp personal recorder/players I have are really very good. Makes you feel sorry for people listening to MP3 players.
I had a Denon DMD1000 but the laser died and was not cost effective to replace, but I still have a Philips portable unit hiding in a box somewhere.
sq225917
11-09-2018, 22:48
always used them in the car still Sony stopped makin them. The last version of ATRAC was always way better than mp3s best efforts.
I've never stopped using the trusty little format, currently got a Sony MDS JB920 QS and looking to buy another as back up.
Mac
The ATRAC system was/is amazingly good.
The reason these decks are going up in price is simple supply and demand. There is still a healthy demand for them, buy supply is becoming limited due to products failing with age and not being repairable.
I used to have an MD deck in my car; far superior as an in car proposition than CDs. I still have a couple of hundred mini discs at home; stupidly sold a really good deck a few years back. I'll buy another when the right one comes up.
i stopped a while ago but still have plenty discs and a couple of sony recording walkmans; one a net type and another just a player in bronze colour. they are as said above very good for recordable media.
the net one is handy for cleaning discs that have been locked electronically.
Powered by vBulletin® Version 4.2.3 Copyright © 2026 vBulletin Solutions, Inc. All rights reserved.