Interesting Chinese field coil 13" driver.

[walpurgis]

Rather decent looking field coil bass drive unit from Queenway of China. Not exactly cheap though!

https://nl.aliexpress.com/item/Lijn-Buis-Magnetische-Versterker-Analoge-Geluid-TA-4151-13-3-inches-Bass-Excitatie-Speaker-VELD-COIL/32869065141.html?spm=a2g0z.10010108.1000016.1.37f2 290f25CR7q&isOrigTitle=true

[Firebottle]

戈登贝内特

[Frazeur1]

^^^Yeah, exactly what he said! Uh...what was it that you said there? :scratch:

[Primalsea]

戈登贝内特

Years ago in a previous job we had a customer called Gorden Bennett. It gets better.. Gorden. F. Bennett! Another guy was called B.J. Wells!

Anyway, yes cor, blimey, that’s a biggun.

[STD305M]

戈登贝内特

meaning Gordon Bennett

[paulf-2007]

Rather decent looking field coil bass drive unit from Queenway of China. Not exactly cheap though!

https://nl.aliexpress.com/item/Lijn-Buis-Magnetische-Versterker-Analoge-Geluid-TA-4151-13-3-inches-Bass-Excitatie-Speaker-VELD-COIL/32869065141.html?spm=a2g0z.10010108.1000016.1.37f2 290f25CR7q&isOrigTitle=true

Kinda lost interest when I saw the price.

[walpurgis]

Kinda lost interest when I saw the price.

The other products from this maker are well worth a look.

[spendorman]

There is a 12" Magnavox field coil speaker in a very very old radio here.

Is there any advantage of field coil units?

[Barry]

Rather decent looking field coil bass drive unit from Queenway of China. Not exactly cheap though!

https://nl.aliexpress.com/item/Lijn-Buis-Magnetische-Versterker-Analoge-Geluid-TA-4151-13-3-inches-Bass-Excitatie-Speaker-VELD-COIL/32869065141.html?spm=a2g0z.10010108.1000016.1.37f2 290f25CR7q&isOrigTitle=true

Probably need a couple of these to drive them properly:

https://nl.aliexpress.com/item/Line-Tube-Magnetic-Amplifier-Analog-Sound-LM-212-Mono-Single-end-Vacuum-Tube-Amplifier-Power-Amplifier/32869313242.html?spm=a2g0z.10010108.1000013.1.75ac 3859Y5BLbN&scm=1007.13339.90158.0&scm_id=1007.13339.90158.0&scm-url=1007.13339.90158.0&pvid=efe986b9-10df-431b-8b2e-f293ae916ee6&_t=pvid%3Aefe986b9-10df-431b-8b2e-f293ae916ee6%2Cscm-url%3A1007.13339.90158.0

[Barry]

There is a 12" Magnavox field coil speaker in a very very old radio here.

Is there any advantage of field coil units?

That one has bothered me for some time. I assume it is historic, as permanent magnets then were not powerful enough (i.e. could not produce sufficient flux density).

However the power supply has to be very well smoothed, otherwise any residual mains hum would modulate the audio signal. Traditionally they ran off 100V and consumed a fair bit of power.

The only advantage of field coils I can see is that you can vary the energising current, and hence the damping.

[struth]

That one has bothered me for some time. I assume it is historic, as permanent magnets then were not powerful enough (i.e. could not produce sufficient flux density).

However the power supply has to be very well smoothed, otherwise any residual mains hum would modulate the audio signal. Traditionally they ran off 100V and consumed a fair bit of power.

The only advantage of field coils I can see is that you can vary the energising current, and hence the damping.

How about back emf has less effect on magnetic field integrity and therefore is more accurate under normal operation.?? dont know, just asking:)

[spendorman]

That one has bothered me for some time. I assume it is historic, as permanent magnets then were not powerful enough (i.e. could not produce sufficient flux density).

However the power supply has to be very well smoothed, otherwise any residual mains hum would modulate the audio signal. Traditionally they ran off 100V and consumed a fair bit of power.

The only advantage of field coils I can see is that you can vary the energising current, and hence the damping.

I suppose that one could Turbo the field coil, over voltage the coil, probably shorten it's life too.

[walpurgis]

There is a 12" Magnavox field coil speaker in a very very old radio here.

Is there any advantage of field coil units?

I can't think why there should be. I think fans just like the 'aura' of a sort of exclusivity.

[paulf-2007]

The other products from this maker are well worth a look.
Yes some nice kit, I have too many projects lined up already and not enough time.