Log in

View Full Version : Cartridge dampers/spacers/weights



CageyH
14-05-2015, 09:13
I need a tad more weight on my cartridges to balance out nicely with the counterweight close to the pivot point.
I have seen Mpingo and graphite spacers on ebay.

The graphite one is from AudioSilente in Italy - http://www.audiosilente.com/spessori_testina.html who are currently at Munich, have all sorts of interesting looking graphite products.

The Mpingo spacer is from the seller "Asantewood".

Does anybody have any experience of these products that they could kindly share?

Barry
14-05-2015, 09:19
What is wong with using a piece of lead shim?

Marco
14-05-2015, 09:19
Hi Kevin,

Yes, I use one of these little chaps to great effect: http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/like/171336377021?limghlpsr=true&hlpv=2&ops=true&viphx=1&hlpht=true&lpid=108&chn=ps&device=c&rlsatarget=&adtype=pla&crdt=0&ff3=1&ff11=ICEP3.0.0-L&ff12=67&ff13=80&ff14=108&ff19=0

Not specifically for adding weight, but for damping resonance (such as with the plastic body-shell on a DL-103 cartridge). If you want to try a wooden spacer, my advice would be to contact Speedy Steve, as he does beautiful ones made from solid ebony, much cheaper than any of the sellers on ebay :)

Marco.

CageyH
14-05-2015, 09:30
Have a look at the Italian site Marco.
It's the same thing, at half the price. http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/GRAPHITE-MC-STABILIZER-SMORZATORE-VIBRAZIONI-PER-TESTINA-GIRADISCHIIN-GRAFITE-HD-/251599599502?pt=LH_DefaultDomain_101&hash=item3a9481378e

CageyH
14-05-2015, 09:31
What is wong with using a piece of lead shim?

I would need to buy some lead out of which I could make a shim. :)

Barry
14-05-2015, 09:33
I would need to buy some lead out of which I could make a shim. :)

Fair enough. :)

Marco
14-05-2015, 10:27
Have a look at the Italian site Marco.
It's the same thing, at half the price. http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/GRAPHITE-MC-STABILIZER-SMORZATORE-VIBRAZIONI-PER-TESTINA-GIRADISCHIIN-GRAFITE-HD-/251599599502?pt=LH_DefaultDomain_101&hash=item3a9481378e

That's cool. Well in that case, get one, as I can confirm its efficacy. If you have any problems with the lingo (should you be in contact with the seller, and his English is poor), just let me know and I'll be glad to help :)

Marco.

Audio Al
14-05-2015, 10:52
If you have any problems with the lingo

Do they speak Scottish in Italy :scratch:
;)

Marco
14-05-2015, 10:57
Yerse, and fluent Daftee! :D

Marco.

Audio Al
14-05-2015, 10:58
Yerse, and fluent Daftee! :D

Marco.

:lol:

Tarzan
19-05-2015, 07:50
I need a tad more weight on my cartridges to balance out nicely with the counterweight close to the pivot point.
I have seen Mpingo and graphite spacers on ebay.

The graphite one is from AudioSilente in Italy - http://www.audiosilente.com/spessori_testina.html who are currently at Munich, have all sorts of interesting looking graphite products.

The Mpingo spacer is from the seller "Asantewood".

Does anybody have any experience of these products that they could kindly share?

Hi Kevin, l used an ART Graphite Damper( which looks identical to the item on the left of your link) on my Gyrodec/SME V/ Denon DL103, and this was to make the cartridge 'taller' as the back of the SME would hit the record being played if it had a warp, well l have to say it had a very positive impact on sound ( because of the extra mass) l would say go for it!:)

Tarzan
19-05-2015, 07:54
Would like to add that this was 'BCB' the damper really brought out the best bits of the SME V/DL103 combo, really full propulsive bass and all day listening.:cool:,

CageyH
19-05-2015, 08:11
Andy,

Thanks for the feedback.
The choice is between a hardwood, Delrin or graphite spacer.

Ammonite Audio
20-05-2015, 17:18
I can't comment on the best type of spacer to use, but I can confirm that the service from Simone at Audio Silente is top notch.

paskinn
20-05-2015, 17:30
For those using modern SME arms, it's worth remembering that the company makes a nice 'spacer' which adds mass and also provides additional clearance for the 309, 4 and V arms. That way you don't need to worry about warps.

surayne
21-05-2015, 10:54
Soundsmith make an interesting set of cartridge thumbscrews which have varying weights, made from different materials (brass, steel and nylon I think). Might be an easy way to add mass.

http://snvinyl.co.uk/epages/eshop943300.mobile/?ObjectPath=/Shops/eshop943300/Products/SSEZ&Locale=en_GB

CageyH
02-11-2015, 19:46
After 6 months, I have finally placed the order for a 4mm graphite spacer from Audio Silente.

I don't believe in rushing these things. :eyebrows:

walpurgis
02-11-2015, 19:54
Why does it need to be made of graphite?

I've made them from Paxolin and Tufnol sheet. Or heavier items from roofing lead or brass.

CageyH
02-11-2015, 19:56
Graphite is supposed to be good for vibration damping.
I just fancied giving it a try.

CageyH
10-11-2015, 06:32
The spacer arrived yesterday. It looks very well made.
I fitted it to my SAE 1000LT last night. It seems to have made a slight improvement on the overall sound, but not a massive one. It still sounds very good.

I think that this is my favourite cartridge. I am just kicking myself that I didn't order a spare.

DSJR
10-11-2015, 11:11
Cheap cartridge damper - an oblong of green (card table) baize between cartridge top and shell, especially if the shell is perforated as in the SME's. More permanent is the black-tac that SME introduced (works too for their perforated shells). Tom Fletcher also suggested a thin smear of glycerine between flat cartridge tops (Deccapod) and flat headshells (his Mentor arm in this case). Bloody things almost stuck together as it dried out...

bob4333
19-11-2015, 07:56
I fitted it to my SAE 1000LT last night.............

.........I think that this is my favourite cartridge. I am just kicking myself that I didn't order a spare.

+1 And so impressed I did order a spare. I'm still looking, but this is the cartridge I keep coming back to. Has beaten cartridges at 4 times the price

But, do I need a spare for the spare while they're still available............?

CageyH
19-11-2015, 08:35
I didn't think they were still available?

bob4333
19-11-2015, 09:36
Yes, it does appear the LT has finally sold out: new news to me so apologies. Bought my spare back in March this year so they were still there then.

But it appears the SAE 1000E is still there (which some prefer) and for the money it's a no-brainer. https://www.thakker.eu/en/pickup/sae-1000e-cartridge/a-5170/

CageyH
16-12-2015, 07:16
The LT is back in stock.
I may have to get myself a spare, just wondering if it should be an E or another LT.

bob4333
16-12-2015, 07:38
Yes, looks like it!

I wonder where Thakker got some more from? I couldn't find anyone else currently stocking them and when checking after your note had assumed he'd finally sold the lot!

As they're now all NOS then however many E's and LT's are left the stock must be finite. The E does get some good press on the 'net. Tough decision, but then it is Christmas................

CageyH
16-12-2015, 08:12
I know what the LT sounds like, but have never heard the E.
That is what makes it tough. I have read the reports though, so I am tempted by the E.

helma
23-03-2018, 16:10
I'll bump up an old thread since I was playing around with cartridge spacers again - I need to shim my cartridges to get good VTA with my Lenco since the arm is mounted on the top plate and the platter on the Lenco sits very low in a recess, so the FR-54 doesn't go low enough to get good VTA without spacers. I've pretty much always noticed a difference between no spacer / spacer, even when adjusting VTA accordingly (on a deck where I can do that). Interestingly I think always the change has been positive with adding a spacer, even if usually quite subtle. So yesterday I was looking at my AT30E and figured the VTA could be a tad lower to be optimal and I needed a new spacer for that. Looking at what I have available, I took two pieces of 3-layer wooden blocks. Actually it's kind of like particle board sandwiched between two thin layers of veneer. I needed to put two of these pieces on top of each other to get about 5mm spacer. I used a bit of superglue to stick them together, cut them to size and drilled holes for screws. I replaced the existing 3mm spacer with this new one - the old spacer was of similar 3-layer construction, except the middle layer is solid wood as well. Of course the new one, being made of two pieces is actually six layers now.

I have used aluminum spacers in the past with good success, also different DIY wood spacers. I've noticed the wood spacers tend to sound a bit softer, the bass is not as tight as with the aluminum ones but the effect is very subtle and with some cartridges the wood spacers can help with midrange, making it a bit more 'lush'. I had high expectations for my new spacer, since I figured the weird particleboard mush in the middle would be great for damping and also it would let me fine tune VTA - with the old spacer I just have to drop the arm as low as it can go and then it's in ballpark. Well, I spin a record and what do you know, it sounds like shit. I mean absolutely horrible, oddly lean yet boomy bass, weird hollow sound to the midrange and just very ill defined overall. Not at all what I expected, I remounted the cartridge, tried different screws with varying amounts of torque but nothing helped, sounds awful. I even changed to my Ortofon MC10 Supreme to check out if everything just sounds like crap to my ears, but no, that cartridge with it's aluminum spacer sounded just fine. Back to the AT30E and yes, it sounds horrible. I switched back to the old spacer and all is good in the world again. That was by far the more pronounced effect I've ever heard a spacer have and it was not good in this case...

Anyway, my recent experience with that spacer that totally killed the sound got me curious - I used to think the material of the spacer doesn't matter that much and all the differences are rather subtle, but I learned differently. I mean this change was not subtle at all, it was way beyond any change of VTA for example, or different platter mats. So, what are the best sounding spacers you have used, and which cartridge and headshell you used them with and did you compare to any other type of spacer?