For £200 you can get a Thorens TD-160 which IMHO is better than either of the OP's options
No built in Phono stage though but they can be had for little money these days, as long as you don't want one with a recognised Hi-Fi name on it, often around £20 for something to get you started.
Current setup Thorens TD-160 Mk1 with Denon DL-110 MC Cartridge, Pioneer PD-8700 CD Player, Yamaha AX-592 Amp, Yamaha CDX-810 CD Player, Yamaha KX-480 Cassette Deck, Yamaha TX-492RDS Tuner, Monitor Audio Bronze 5 speakers, Van-Damme Cables throughout.