Miyajima Shilabe - first impressions
I know that when I'm researching a new component AOS member impressions always count more than any other, including paid reviews. So I like to add to the knowledge bank by adding my own 2 penneth worth whenever a new component or accessory passes the threshold.
I gave my initial impressions when the Allaerts arrived and updated it over the following weeks. Well today I mounted my new Miyajima Shilabe and will give a few impressions...
Here's caveat 1 - this was a demo unit from fellow member Hugo of Ammonite Acoustics and had done around 25 LP sides before coming my way. So not anywhere near the recommended 60-100 hour play time for peak performance, but neither straight out of the box.
Here's caveat 2 - my impressions are running the Miyajima straight into the Vida's MC input which doesn't load the cart at the manufacturers recommended 250ohms.
I'm reliably informed that although it actually sounds very good into the Vida with its less than perfect loading, even better performance can be had by using a good SUT such as the Hashimoto H7 or even a top notch head amp - although I'm tempted by the Miyajima KSW dedicated SUT which of course loads it correctly. But this decision is next month. Right now it's Vida only.
Appearance
The Shilabe is a thing of understated beauty, at least in my eyes. It's very different to the chunky square shape of the gold Allaerts, with its rounded polished African Blackwood body. The cantilever is also rather businesslike and 'rugged' in comparison - though I like it.
Set up
I was crapping myself fixing this to the Siggwan arm with its integral wooden headshell. (pics to follow) The Shilabe needs to be fixed bolt side up which means somehow securing the screw heads from underneath so they don't move while the bolts are fixed from above - not easy but doable.
This was very fiddly and didn't give me confidence for setting overhang and alignment BUT it was actually very very easy. I was surprised that I got it right first time - aligned spot on with zero sibilance, perfect central imaging of female vocals with no obvious crosstalk - I'm very sensitive to this. Infact it was easier than the Allaerts.
I didn't need to adjust azimuth or VTA - it was spot on with the cart parallel with the vinyl.
Readjusting tracking force was easy - I'm tracking it at 3g - with the Siggwan loaded at an effective mass of 18g - copying Frank Schroder's preferred settings.
The sound
Bearing in mind the lack of break in I was surprised by how good it sounded 'cold' but after only a few hours play time there was a very audible improvement - which of course promises good things for the future.
I guess a recap of the Allaerts is in order.
- Stunning resolution
- Perfectly flat response
- Holographic pinpoint imaging
- sublime vocals
- Wide, deep and tall soundstage.
Perfect, right? Well almost. The Vida loads the Allaert at its optimum setting but if the cart has one minor weakness it's a slight lack of boogy factor and perhaps the final nuances of timbre.
The Shilabe
This cart has balls! Even at the wrong loading it has the most profound bass I've ever heard from vinyl. Not warm flabby bass but cavernous, controlled earth moving bass that is going to cause problems with my neighbours!
This, and the carts reputation (which I can now confirm) for being faster at transients than any other cart because of it's unusual construction, accounts for a tremendous boogie factor. It sweeps you up into the performance in a way the Allaerts doesn't - amazing.
Soundstage is actually very very good, with a wider spread than the Allaerts, but not quite as deep (I'm being very picky) and not as much height. The imaging is excellent but again not quite up to the Allaerts with its 70db of channel separation. But the Miyajima spreads a wonderful tapestry before you and around you - dense and rich.
Vocals are beautifully portrayed, not quite as ethereal as the Allaerts but with more body. Dianna Krall has a new chestiness that adds to the sum of the whole. Less holographic and walk around but more visceral and in 'my' room rather than a holodeck. I like it. Multilayered vocals dont have quite the same air around them - yet.
Cello and piano have actually taken on a new realism, which I thought impossible. Timbre is sublime, truly - and with a grandeur the Allaerts just doesn't have.
Electronica is a minor revelation, mainly due to the apparent extra bottom octave of clean bass. I'd read that the Miyajima wasn't a cart for electronica - crap. Yello's Toy sounds truly awesome - incredibly dynamic and multilayered. Stunning.
Percussive instruments (I have a thing for Japanese percussion) is extraordinary. Timbre and decay as well as leading edges are superb and bring a whole new realism.
With the Allaerts you are watching a performance, beautiful yes but you are a voyeur and not a participant. With the Miyajima you are pulled into an event, embraced by it, bewitched by it. And that's with less than perfect loading or break in. Am I a happy bunny - oh yes.
PS. A quick thank you to Hugo of Ammonite and also Tom and Mike for their help and advice.
Adey
In perpetual pursuit.
Technics SP10 mk2
Jan Allaerts MC 1 Boron mk1 cart
Miyajima Shilabe cart
Hashimoto HM-X SUT
Siggwan (gimballed not unipivot) Cocobola 12"
Aurorasound Vida LCR Phonostage
The Truth linestage
Dave Slagle Autoformer Volume Controller
Cary 805c SET amps
Audio Note ANe-SPX speakers
Townshend Isolda speaker cables
Cardas Golden Presence interconnects