Do our idols owe us a living?

[Spectral Morn]

I agree Atom Heart mother live with a Brass band would be amazing. Did it ever happen, I suppose it must have ?

Regards D S D L---- Neil

[Beechwoods]

Oh yes, lots of times - with local orchestras and choirs often, though the same conductor. The musicians would sight-read and sometimes the results were better than others It was also played as a 4 piece as well, and works in that format - the Floyd could improvise more without the orchestra and other musicians playing along.

[muffinman]

Waters is worth listening to is because he has something to say, usually something he is unhappy about whereas Gilmour has a more or less idyllic existence and can just about manage to tell us about a walk with his wife down by the river (they had a picnic).

I was excited about on an island but when i heard that tinkling picnic song, i actually felt angry. probably not the mood he was hoping to portray.
Beechy is right about waters being embarrasing though. i saw him in '06&'07 and both times had to put up with a song called 'leaving beruit'. utter dogshit.
his heart's in the right place but his head is often up his arse
on the comeback front though, if they ('pink floyd')announced a world tour tomorrow, it'd be sold out tomorrow. and the same goes for zep.